| MEN | ||
| Atte Tolvanen * | Northern Michigan | 2018 |
| Evan Weninger | Omaha | 2018 |
| Michael Garteig | Quinnipiac | 2013 |
| Mitch Gillam* | Cornell | 2013 |
| Kyle Richter | Harvard | 2008 |
| Jon Quick | Massachusetts | 2007 |
| Mike Mantua* | Western Michigan | 2002 |
| Chad Alban* | Michigan State | 1998 |
| Andy Allen | Vermont | 1998 |
| Damian Rhodes | Michigan Tech | 1989 |
| Jim Tortorella | Maine | 1980 |
| WOMEN | ||
| Corinne Schroeder | Quinnipiac | 2021 |
* Shot the puck directly into the net